Your Marketing Budget Could Become Someone Else’s Income

Editor
5 Min Read

People tend to put “impact” into a separate CSI or ESG box, while an organisation may be spending millions every year on events, catering, gifts, merchandise, printing, flowers, furniture and employee experiences. That is economic power. Imagine if companies looked at even a percentage of that everyday spend and asked: who could this money create an opportunity for?

The specific moment when I began to understand what this could mean happened while working on a Bakers Zoo Biscuits project. Instead of producing a conventional promotional item, we developed a giant Zoo Biscuit cushion and worked with an initiative in Orange Farm to produce it.

Although the cushion answered the creative brief and was fun, completely original, memorable and deeply connected to the brand, somewhere along the way I realised that the marketing budget had become somebody else’s income. No additional CSI budget had to be found because the company was already going to spend that money. We had simply made a different decision about where it went.

That experience changed the way I looked at corporate procurement and ultimately led to GE-SKENK. Companies spend money on gifts, events, campaigns and branded items every day, so I began with a simple question: what happens if we use some of that existing spend more intentionally?

Over the years, we have built a network of South African makers, small businesses, social enterprises and community organisations into the work we do for corporate clients. The work still has to be brilliant, answer the brand brief, fit into budgets and work commercially. Social impact should never become an excuse for mediocre work.

After 15 years of working with local makers and entrepreneurs, I have seen that the biggest barrier is often access. Corporate procurement systems tend to favour businesses that already have scale, cash flow, compliance infrastructure and existing relationships, despite the extraordinary work being produced by small South African businesses.

For many small suppliers, corporate access can mean being expected to finance large orders, wait for payment terms, quote repeatedly without certainty and meet unrealistic turnaround times. A maker may comfortably produce 50 units and then suddenly a corporate buyer wants 500 in two weeks.

Having an intermediary involved can help those two worlds work together. We understand the corporate environment and the supplier environment, so part of our role is designing a solution that works for both. Corporate access needs to be commercially viable access, otherwise it is not really access at all.

Businesses that genuinely want their spending to create local impact should begin by looking at what they already buy and identifying realistic opportunities to source from local makers, women-owned businesses or social enterprises. Those intentions need to form part of the brief from the beginning because it is very difficult to create meaningful impact when somebody phones three days before an event wanting 1,000 units at the cheapest possible price.

Giving smaller businesses reasonable lead times, workable payment terms and the opportunity to grow into larger projects creates the conditions in which they have a genuine chance to succeed. Companies should buy from them because they are good businesses, rather than treating social impact as charity.

There are times when we turn work down because the budget cannot support what a supplier needs to charge or the lead time would place unreasonable pressure on a small producer. Sometimes somebody wants “social impact” attached to a project without being prepared to invest properly in it.

While it would often be commercially convenient to say yes, squeeze the supplier and make the job happen, I do not believe that is impact. A successful project has to work for the client and for the people producing it. Otherwise, somebody further down the chain is paying for the lovely story being told at the top.

What matters most to me is how money moves through the businesses I build, who gets access to it and whether the work leaves something useful behind. A R100,000 order to a large supplier might be another job number. To a small business, it can change their year.

Every spreadsheet ultimately has people behind it.

By Vicki Scheffel, founder of GE-SKENK 

Share This Article