Employers Cannot Demand Loyalty They Have Not Earned

Editor
5 Min Read

Employers often talk about employee entitlement, usually when they feel people expect too much from a job. After years in recruitment, I have seen that entitlement can exist on the employer’s side too. Some expect that offering someone a job and a salary should automatically earn their gratitude and loyalty.

While a salary covers the basics, employers need to work to attract and keep good people. If you want the best from your team, you need to create an environment that is genuinely pleasant to work in, where people can build meaningful connections and feel that they are adding value. Plenty of companies can offer a job and a salary. Very few make their employees feel truly valued and fulfilled.

After years of helping people build their careers, I have come to understand that we are all trying to create happy, prosperous lives for ourselves and our families. Careers are a means to that and, when you choose the right one, it can give you purpose beyond the pay cheque.

My approach to leadership has been shaped by working under many different types of leaders. One leader prioritised a happy working environment over profit. We had a high-performing individual whose behaviour had become toxic and, instead of tolerating it because of the return they generated, the company let them go. That decision stayed with me.

Other leaders taught me what I did not want to repeat. I have worked for people who micromanaged to the point where nobody was trusted to do their job. I have also seen leaders use restraint-of-trade clauses to trap employees instead of earning their loyalty. I want to build a leadership style where my team feels trusted and valued, without control or fear shaping the relationship.

I once fired a client because they were treating my team badly and I felt uncomfortable putting candidates into that environment. Walking away was difficult financially, but I kept thinking about the leader who had chosen a healthy culture over profit. That example gave me the conviction to make the same choice.

At The Make It Good Company, the recruitment agency I am building in the marketing, advertising and technology space, what matters most to me is doing things properly and with integrity. Recruitment has a bad reputation because too many people cut corners for a quick buck or fling CVs around without really engaging with candidates. I wanted to build something different.

Our approach is to work as a consultative partner. For clients, that means advising on hiring strategy, role structure and pricing alongside helping them find the right person. For candidates, it means being someone they can genuinely approach for career advice. We are all people dealing with real life and I want every engagement to be based on listening, understanding and showing up for one another.

Technology has an important role to play in helping us work efficiently, although it can never come at the expense of integrity or human connection. There is a lot of talk about AI putting recruiters out of work. I believe that risk applies to those who work transactionally. Keeping human connection at the heart of recruitment will keep our work relevant and meaningful.

Building my own business has also made me hyperaware of the distinction between commercial success and creating a company where people genuinely want to stay and grow. Achieving both comes with sacrifices, although I prefer to think of them as investments. If a decision means giving up some profit so that the team can feel fulfilled, it is worth making.

For me, being a good businessperson means acting with integrity and prioritising your employees’ needs. There will always be difficult decisions ahead, but I hope to make them with those values at heart, finding the balance between what is right for the business and what is right for the people in it.

If employers want good people to choose their business and keep choosing it, they have to offer them a reason that reaches beyond the pay cheque.

By Faye Ross, director and recruiter at The Make It Good Company

Share This Article