When Our Own Stars No Longer Shine: A Call to Reclaim the South African Music Awards
Yesterday, the South African Music Awards happened. I’m a musician, and I barely knew about it. That’s not me being careless — that’s where we are now. The SAMAs used to mean something. They used to mean everything. Now? Most of us in the industry didn’t even realize they were happening. We need to talk about how we got here.
The Day That Stopped a Nation
I remember when the SAMAs meant the whole country stopped. Not just musicians — everyone. Politicians, business people, athletes, teachers, families. Everyone gathered around their TVs. The SAMAs weren’t just an industry event. They were a South African event. The cultural weight of that night was massive — think about what the Grammys mean in America. That’s what the SAMAs used to be for us.
Now? Yesterday came and went. Barely a mention on social media. Artists weren’t there. Fans didn’t care. All that energy that used to exist around this event — the red carpet, the interviews, the collaborations, the conversations the next day — it’s gone. We’ve let the SAMAs shrink from something the whole nation cared about to something most people don’t even notice.
The Global Recognition Problem
Look, South African artists are doing big things internationally. Tyla’s success shows the world is paying attention to what we’re creating here. The Grammys, BET Awards, international festivals — these matter. They prove our music can compete anywhere.
But here’s what bothers me: we get more excited about global recognition than we do about our own awards. South African fans wait for the world to tell them who their best artists are before they take notice.
I’m not saying international validation isn’t important. It is. Competing globally means you’re meeting world class standards. But we can’t let chasing international recognition make us forget about our own institutions. When we do that, we’re saying our own people’s validation doesn’t matter as much. We’re teaching the next generation that you only matter if you get recognized overseas first.
The flag we carry internationally is our South African flag. The culture we’re exporting comes from here — from our communities, our townships, our experiences. Recognition abroad should add to what we’re celebrating at home, not replace it. When we neglect the SAMAs, we’re neglecting ourselves.
To the Judges, Can You See What You’ve Done?
To everyone who’s been a SAMA judge over the years — can you honestly look at where we are now and say you did justice to this industry?
Year after year, artists and fans complained about winners who didn’t make sense. Albums of the Year that nobody heard. Songs of the Year that weren’t playing anywhere. Artist of the Year awards going to people fans had to Google. Many South Africans only heard certain winners’ names for the first time at the awards ceremony itself. That’s not okay.
I get it — the SAMAs aren’t supposed to be just a popularity contest. Craft matters. Innovation matters. Technical excellence matters. Sometimes the best work isn’t the most popular, and that deserves recognition. But there has to be balance. When regular people — the fans who buy music, stream songs, attend shows — can’t recognize or relate to who’s winning, something’s wrong.
This disconnect has been building for years. Fans stopped trusting that the SAMAs reflected reality. Artists stopped believing the awards were fair. And slowly, we all stopped caring.
To the judges who contributed to this — you need to own it. These awards lost credibility because of decisions made behind closed doors, year after year, that ignored what was actually happening in our music scene. The apathy we’re seeing now didn’t come from nowhere. It’s the result of people feeling shut out and disrespected.
Artists, We Need to Show Up
But we can’t just blame judges and organizers. We as artists have to look at ourselves too.
When we don’t show up, we’re part of the problem. When someone wins an award and the stage is empty because they couldn’t be bothered to attend, what message does that send to fans? When we prioritize international gigs over our own national awards, we’re saying the SAMAs don’t matter. When we’re quiet on social media during the SAMAs but lose our minds celebrating Grammy nominations, we’re teaching South Africans to devalue their own.
These are our awards. They belong to us — the musicians, producers, composers, engineers, everyone who makes South African music happen. If we don’t fight for them, who will?
Showing up to the SAMAs isn’t just about collecting trophies. It’s about connecting with fans who support us. It’s about engaging with media who amplify our work. It’s about meeting industry leaders, creating new collaborations, giving content creators opportunities. It’s about mentoring younger artists by showing them what it means to honor your craft and your community. It’s about showing up for South Africa.
We need to make ourselves available. We need to participate. We need to care.
RISA Needs to Lead the Change
We can’t talk about fixing the SAMAs without talking about RISA — the Recording Industry of South Africa. They run these awards, and they need to lead the reform.
This industry has given me everything. My career, my platform, my life. That’s why I won’t stop talking about what needs to change. RISA needs to make the judging process transparent. They need panels with diverse voices — not just the same gatekeepers but people who are actually in touch with what’s happening: young curators, regional representatives, specialists across different genres.
RISA needs to rebuild trust. That means accountability, transparency, and a real commitment to recognizing excellence wherever it comes from.
It’s a lot of work, but it’s not impossible. Other countries have reformed their music awards to better reflect what’s actually happening. We can do the same. But it takes leadership with vision and the guts to make real changes, not just surface-level adjustments.
What We Could Have Again
Imagine the SAMAs mattering again. Artists clearing their calendars months ahead because being there is non-negotiable. Fans debating nominations because the awards actually reflect the music they hear and love. A SAMA win carrying the same weight as any international award. The ceremony becoming this amazing moment where creativity is celebrated, networks are built, and culture is showcased.
We could have that again. But it takes all of us wanting it.
Artists need to show up with the same energy we bring to international opportunities. Judges need to do their jobs with integrity and transparency. RISA needs to lead real reform. Media needs to cover the SAMAs like the major cultural event they should be. Sponsors need to invest properly. And fans need to demand excellence and hold everyone accountable.
What We’re Teaching the Next Generation
I think about young musicians coming up right now — kids in townships, suburbs, rural areas, practicing in bedrooms, performing in small venues, dreaming big. What are we teaching them when we can’t even keep our most visible institution alive?
If we let the SAMAs fade completely, we’re robbing them of something to work toward. We’re telling them only international validation matters. We’re destroying the infrastructure that should support and celebrate them throughout their careers — not just if they happen to break through globally.
They deserve better. We deserve better. South Africa deserves better.
The SAMAs used to represent the peak of our industry — a night when the country celebrated its musicians, when being nominated meant something real, when winning proved you’d made a cultural impact. That version of the SAMAs is worth fighting for.
But fighting for it means actually doing something. Artists showing up. Judges being fair. RISA leading properly. All of us deciding that our own institutions matter.
What Has Happened Now
Yesterday, the SAMAs happened and most of South Africa didn’t notice. We can accept that as normal, or we can do something about it.
We can fight for the SAMAs the way we fight for international recognition. We can hold judges accountable. We can show up and participate. We can demand that RISA does better. We can preserve this for the musicians coming after us.
The SAMAs are ours. Their future depends on whether we care enough to save them.
I care. I’m calling on every artist, everyone in the industry, every fan, every South African who’s ever been moved by our music — let’s do this together.
These are our awards. Our industry. Our culture.
Let’s reclaim it.
Zakes Bantwini is a Grammy Award-winning musician, producer, and founder of Mayonie Productions. He holds Jazz and popular music qualifications from UKZN, a Social Entrepreneurship qualification from GIBS Pretoria University, and a Business of Entertainment Media and Sports qualification from Harvard Business School, and has dedicated his career to advancing South African music both locally and internationally.
By Zakes Bantwini
